SchoolFamily Voices

In this space, SchoolFamily.com brings you the expertise, opinions, and thoughts from a variety of guest bloggers. Please feel free to comment on each of their blog posts. If you have someone you'd like to see featured in this space, please email editor@schoolfamily.com.

Should Schools Discipline Students for Cyber-bullying that Occurs Outside of School?

Posted by on
  • Font size: Larger Smaller
  • Hits: 6679
  • Subscribe to this entry
  • Print

Just finished reading the New York Times article "Online Bullies Pull Schools into the Fray." If you have kids in grades 4-9, I strongly recommend that you read this article. But be forewarned, it will leave your head spinning. The examples of cyber-bulling via cellphones and social media sites, such as Facebook, Formspring and Youtube, are mind-numbing and disturbing. You are left saying, "How can kids be so cruel?" ... and ... "Maybe I should monitor my kids texts and Facebook pages more often."

But the question this NYT article raises is not about internet safety and monitoring but rather how and where should the bullying harassment be handled?  When kids do cyberbullying outside of school and the school learns of the altercation, should the actions be punishable at school? Talk about gray area. As with so many parenting and teen and tween topics, we are asking the question: where do you draw the proverbial line? You can't deny that if someone sends a nasty text away from school, that there is slim chance that the parties involved will set their differences aside when the walk through the school doors. The hurt will percolate and fester, and eventually a teacher, guidance counselor or principal will hear about it. So, then what's a school to do? We count on our school administrators to promote a safe environment for our children. Isn't anti-bullying part of that? 

What is your take ...  when it comes to matters of extreme cyberbullying (that happen outside of school but spills over into the school day) is it the principal's or school administrator's job to play judge or prosecutor?  Would love to hear your thoughts on this complex and unfortunate question. 




#2 Becki 2010-07-22 20:06
I found Nancy Willard's comments enlightening. But my question is, what happened to slander and libel? I recall from my history textbooks that slander is when a person's resputation is intentionally being damaged. Aren't nasty comments on social media slander? I'd really like to know.
#1 Nancy Willard 2010-07-03 04:36
Hi. Good question. I am the consultant quoted in the article. It is kind of hard to convince reporters to provide the complete legal standard.

There is very good reason to believe, based on cases such as Tinker, Saxe, and Lawshock (plus others), that school administrators have the authority to respond in situations where a student's off-campus speech has caused - or there are good reasons to believe it will cause - a substantial disruption in school or a significant interference with the rights of another student to feel secure.

The three kinds of situations include violent altercations, a significant interference in the ability of another student to participate in instruction and school activities, and significant interference with instruction or school operations.

The question to ask is whether we would want this to be any other way. Would we want a legal standard that would uphold one student's free speech rights as superior to the rights of another student to receive an education and be safe at school?

Nancy Willard
Center for Safe and Responsible Internet Use

Add comment...


Do you allow your children to watch TV or play on the computer before doing their homework?